Sunday, May 20, 2018


photo by Anna Webber

For his fans, the past four years have been a non-stop source of musical wonderment; bountiful blessings in the form of a series of stunningly brilliant solo albums coupled with a near-constant touring schedule. As for the artist himself, he has never been more musically active, never been more content with life than the present. An old soul aglow with the energy of a 19-year-old, David Crosby is, at 76, not giving in an inch.

Crosby remains in full-throttle creative mode. Fresh from completing a new album with his Lighthouse band that includes Snarky Puppy leader/bassist Michael League, singer-songwriter Becca Stevens, and singer-songwriter Michelle Willis, he is back on the road with his Sky Trails band that also features Willis, James Raymond on keyboards and vocals, guitarist Jeff Pevar, bassist Mai Leisz, and drummer Steve DiStanislao. The tour visits Long Island on June 9, at the Westhampton Beach Performing Arts Center.

The musical icon—co-founder of The Byrds, Crosby, Stills and Nash,  and Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young—remains as outspoken as ever, as his legion of Twitter followers will attest to.

Roy Abrams: Mr. Crosby! How are you today, sir?
David Crosby: I’m probably the happiest guy you’re gonna talk to all week!

RA: That seems to be your status quo for the past few years!
DC: [chuckles]

RA: Let’s talk about the album you’re currently working on with the Lighthouse band. I know that Michelle Willis was posting some pretty neat videos of the collaborative songwriting process.
DC: Yeah, it’s been that. We wrote almost the whole record together. I’ve never done that before, really, with four people … kind of an amazing experience – a fully contributive, fully cooperative space. I’ve made music in competitive bands where we make good music – CSN, CSNY, definitely competitive bands – but this is a wonderful, elevating experience. I am kind of freaked out and thrilled by it. We played it for the heads of the record company last night and they loved it. I played it for my wife, and she cried, and that’s always a good sign. I don’t think anybody else is doing this stuff, man. It’s a vocal band, it’s folk instruments; mostly acoustic instruments, and pretty dense vocals … a lot of counterpoint, a lot of harmony, a lot of big stacks of vocals. I hope people are gonna like it, I definitely know I love it.

RA: I cannot wait! Where is the album being recorded?
DC: It’s being recorded at Flux Studios down in Alphabet City in New York. It’s a place run by a man named Fabrice Dupont. He’s a very famous mix engineer, he’s also a very famous recording engineer, and he’s really good.

RA: He mixed the Lighthouse record, which was amazingly good.
DC: He did a great job on that; this is probably four times as good, because we cut it in his space with him. His ability to get sounds is really kind of stellar. I know Michael League, who’s the producer, is just freakin’ thrilled with it.

RA:  I wanted to get some updated insights into the people you’re recording with, given the collaborative nature in which you’re working with Michael, Becca, and Michelle. What are some of the things you’re learning about them, or even from them, in terms of their own unique sensibilities?
DC: Well, you know what I’ve learned? It’s a very reassuring thing. They’re much younger than me; they’re half my age, but they are exactly like me. They are people who have given their life to it; it’s their life. They have the same thing I do: they have family, but that’s the only other thing. There’s family and there’s music. These are people who, at their 30-year-old level, have already done the 10,000 hours. And, they are incredibly talented and incredibly able. The thing is, they’re still in love with it; they don’t have this long, grinding history, you know, that I’ve had with the other guys.  They are still really in love with music, and they are still thrilled that we get a chance to make it. The result has been a record that …  I don’t even have words to describe it, man.  It’s not like anything that anybody else is doing. (We got) really good songs and they got worked on by some of the best vocalists that I’ve ever heard.

RA: I was watching your expression on that video Michelle posted of you, her, and Michael; the vocal jamming with the handclapping, and the phrase that came to mind was “youth eternal.” Given your experiences during the past few years, has your perspective on aging changed at all?
DC: Yeah, you know, as you get older, you can look at it two ways. You can get very frightened by it all, sort of retreat into your own shell, and try to hide from your place in your life. Or, you can say, this is what the real world is, I have a limited amount of time; I’m gonna use every freakin’ second to do the only thing I can do that makes a contribution: to make this music, and make the absolute best music (that) I possibly can. It’s a weird situation, because we’re not getting paid for it. I’m putting the egg money that we need to pay the rent with into this thing, and I’m not gonna get it back. That Lighthouse record you like? I haven’t made a nickel.

RA: Really?!
DC: Not one cent.

RA: I don’t know what to say. For the people who buy the record on CD, none of that comes back to you?
DC: Well, it didn’t. The record company that we had it out on cheated us and so I haven’t gotten anything. I think I’m gonna get paid this time, because I’m with a better record company. But the main point is, the streaming killed us, because nobody buys anything anymore, they just stream it. But the process of making the records is still a complete joy, and it is our art, and it is what we leave behind, and it is so much fun for me, man. Yes, it’s bragging, but I would have never even believed that I could make four records in four years, and have them be really good, and they are, and I did.

RA: Yes, you did!
DC: [chuckles] Yaaay!

photo by Anna Webber

RA: The last time we saw each other, I bumped into you and Jan at the Mercury Lounge for Becca’s show back in January. I don’t know if I even have any words for that, because you weren’t there to sing, you were there to show support. In your early days as an artist, were there older mentors in your life who attended your shows and offered the kind of support that you give to so many others?
DC: Hmmm, no, not that came to my shows or anything. There are people that I followed, and that I learned a lot from: Odetta, Travis Edmonson, Johnny White, Pete Seeger, Woody Guthrie. I never met Woody myself, but all those other people I met, and I learned a lot from them. Joan Baez … that’s where I come from, that folk music thing, and I couldn’t have asked for a better intro to music because it was very genuine stuff, and then, you know, after I struck myself, then I met a whole bunch of people.

RA: I hesitate to go where I’m about to go, because everything you’re doing these days is about forward momentum and you’re so focused on all things new, but there are increasing calls for CSNY to reunite and provide a voice for these troubled times. How appealing is the idea to you personally?
DC: Well, not very appealing if it’s CSN, because that was a pretty unfriendly party. But if you add Neil to it, then there’s a challenge there, because he’s always gonna push the envelope; he’s always gonna try and push the thing out toward the edge, and I like that, I do like that! He doesn’t like me right now, but I do like his music and I do love how he approaches his music. I would say, never say never. I don’t think it’s gonna happen; I don’t think that Graham is gonna outgrow his anger at me, or Neil. They’re both very angry at me; well, I can’t do anything about that. I don’t have any bad feelings about them, or Stephen. I’m fine with them; I wish them no ill at all. I would do it if Neil wanted to do it and I’ll tell you why. I get probably about five messages a day saying, “Would you guys please make up and do your job? The country needs you very badly right now.” They say that over and over again, and they say things like, “You were singing the ‘Let’s Impeach the President’ song of Neil’s, but too soon! The only thing that was off was your timing! Now we have a president who lies all the time. Every word that comes out of his mouth is a lie. Now, the song is entirely appropriate and you assholes should be out here singing it!” [chuckles] And I can’t disagree. I think that we should be out there singing “For What It’s Worth” … you know, young people speaking their mind …. I think we need to be saying that, and I think we should be singing “Ohio.”  And I think we should be singing “Long Time Gone” and “Almost Cut My Hair” and “Chicago.” You know, those songs, they’re fight songs, man, they’re marching songs. They give people the kind of juice that it used to give people to sing “We Shall Overcome” when they were doing the civil rights marches. The music really helps you to gut up to face the situation that you’re facing in the street. As far as that goes, yes, I think we should be doing it, and I would love it if Neil wanted to.

RA: The Carnegie Hall concert that you did with Snarky Puppy a little while back had a lot of that spark, that magic to which you just referred.  What are your reflections of that show? You seemed to be floating on that stage that night.
DC: Well, I loved it. In the first place, I love Snarky Puppy, and I love Michael League—he is one of my really good friends now—and he is an incredible producer and an incredible musician. So, I love working with him, I loved playing with him. I loved that the show had people from all over the world; from England, from Africa, from America, from Canada. It was really international, and really good that way. I really liked that about it. That’s the thing that Michael, who put the show together, is always trying to do; he loves world music. It’s true of Chris Thile, too; he does the same thing. I really admire that in both of them.

RA: What are your thoughts on the Musicambia benefit that just took place in NYC?
DC: It’s a wonderful thing. (It was started by) this guy, Nate Schramm. He’s the one who married Becca, and he’s the violist in one of the best string quartets on the East Coast, the Attacca Quartet. He was in Venezuela and he saw something really fascinating. He said that the government was terrible, but they did a wonderful thing: they had music education programs in the prisons. He said that really sparked his mind, because it was very definitely making a difference. So, he started that up here. That’s what Musicambia does; they take music education into prisons. They’re very brave about it, and they do it very well. These are schooled musicians, not like me; I’m illiterate. They really know what they’re doing and they can teach it. I was in a prison; I know what it’s like. I know how much a difference it makes if you do something that gives you some sense of self-worth. At that point, your self-worth is really on the bottom of the floor. And knowing what it’s like to be able to create art in there, and to be able to do something beautiful in the middle of what’s a devastatingly bad situation … if you have music, music’s a lifting force, man. It makes it all better. I completely support this idea, so that’s why I did that.

RA: I recently read that Cameron Crowe is producing a documentary on you. How did that come to pass?
DC: Cameron’s been my friend since he was 16 years old. [laughs] He knows me really well. He has an incredible gift as an interviewer; he always did. He gets stuff out of me that nobody else can. So we have these interviews that are remarkable; they are, above all, honest. They are not self-serving. They are not, “Oh, then I discovered California, and right after that I invented electricity.” It’s probably going to be the most honest documentary on anybody that you’ve ever seen.

RA:  That’s cool. Is there a tentative release date?
DC: My guess, since BMG is paying for it, that they want to release this record and that documentary at the same time so they get cross-talk in the same field.

RA: That’s great! I also hear you’re working on another book.
DC: Well, I’m trying to! The guy who I’m trying to write it with called while we were talking, just now. I have to call him back as soon as I get off with you. Yes, we’re trying to get a deal to write a book about current politics and what I feel about the United States of America. I’m a kind of corny believer, strongly believing in democracy and the United States. I don’t think we have it right now, but I do love it. I like the idea very much, and I’m trying to defend it any way I can.

RA: I’m assuming that you’ve seen Emma Gonzalez’s various speeches?
DC: I have seen some of her stuff, and (David) Hogg’s too. I am really happy about those guys.

RA:  What are your thoughts on the emerging youth movement?
DC: They’re pissed, man. Look at it! We’re handing them a really seriously damaged world, we’re handing them a broken democracy, we’re handing them an America with the scab torn off of the racism so it’s blatant, and then the president pours gasoline on the fire and says, “Racism cool, yeah! We wanna be right-wing, racist assholes … real good!” He’s encouraging the worst part. That’s the world we’re handing them! Of course they’re gonna stand up and take a stand. I’m so proud of them, I’m so happy about them, and I want to encourage them any way I can, but I really don’t think they need us; I think they to be them; they don’t need any grownups telling them what to do.

RA: Their organizational skills, their use of social media to rally the troops is nothing short of mind boggling.
DC: If they can get the kids out to vote, we’re gonna take the Congress back, and then we can start repairing all the damage … that would be really good. In terms of global warming, I don’t think we have the time to waste. We have to get it back on track.

RA: Are you familiar with The Ocean Cleanup project which was started by a Dutch teenager named Boyan Slat?
DC: Yeah. I think that that’s gonna continue. When I see that, I feel encouraged. When I see the orange-headed disaster in the White House, I feel very discouraged. Listen, I’ve got to call another person, and it’s kind of a drag, because you’re really fun to talk to!

RA: Same here, David. Thank you so much for your time.
DC: It’s my pleasure, man.

© 2018 by Roy Abrams

Sunday, December 10, 2017

Wizard of Ahhs: The Magical Mind of Ben Bloomberg

Those familiar with British wunderkind Jacob Collier will attest to his otherworldly level of musical talent. They will also, no doubt, be familiar with the young American whose technological wizardry allows Jacob to realize his most innovative ideas. In the same manner in which Collier represents, according to guitar legend Steve Vai, a “paradigm shift in music history,” Ben Bloomberg brings a new realm of possibilities to the fields of live and recorded performance. Bloomberg is an MIT graduate student with an impressive CV that reveals an intellect reaching stratospheric heights of insight and application, resulting in a myriad of technological achievements that can only be termed stunning.


Ben Bloomberg in a comfortable environment
image courtesy of Ben Bloomberg

Having seen Jacob Collier in concert several times during the past year, I got to speak with Ben before and after some of the shows. Backstage at The Roof at Output in Brooklyn—the final show of a whirlwind series of performances—I asked him if he would like to arrange a “proper” interview, and he graciously agreed. So, on a Saturday afternoon in early September, while taking a much-needed respite at his home in Cambridge, Massachusetts, we spent the better part of an hour on the phone. What follows is our complete conversation, slightly edited for clarity. Read on and learn more about a true American innovator, one whose path seemed almost preordained from a very early age …

Roy Abrams: So, you actually have a little time off right now, eh? It must be nice to get some down time in! You’re leaving again soon with Jacob, I understand.

Ben Bloomberg: Yeah, we’re actually going to go to London and we’re working on the music room [Jacob’s recording studio, located in his North London home].

RA: Jacob plans to start recording a new album, correct?

BB: I think it’s going to be pretty soon. We’re setting up the music room for the next round of writing and recording. We don’t know exactly what the schedule is yet, but basically the idea is as the solo shows wind down, to keep things low-key for a little bit, so he can write and work on his next album.

RA: The partnership between the two of you can easily be described as a cosmically ordained kind of thing. I spent several hours on your website over the past couple of days and, well, if you remember Jacob’s Bowery Ballroom show back in February when some guy yelled out “Dude, what the hell?!” during his encore performance of “Blackbird,” I can basically say the same thing, and hurl that one at you! You really had your first live sound experience at age 9?

BB: [Laughs] I grew up in Northampton, Massachusetts, which has a lot of music … so there was a band on my street that played Bar Mitzvahs and parties and things like that, and they were around my parents’ age. They were called The Blenders. They needed somebody to set up the speakers and stuff like that. I think they paid me $5 an hour. I would plug in the speakers and microphones and then watch—mix is kind of a strong word—but I would keep an eye on things during the show.

RA: What drew you toward sound in the first place?

BB: To be honest, even when I was really, really little, my Dad taught me how to use the record player, and I used to listen to records, like The Cars and Earth, Wind & Fire, and the Glenn Miller Orchestra, Elvis Costello. I had a record player in my room, so from a kind of very young age, I just always enjoyed listening to music, and then in fourth grade, my elementary school got a new sound system and nobody bothered to learn how to use it except me; I was just excited because it was bigger speakers, and I liked electronics and computers a little bit back then as well, so I got to learn how to use it. Then it became my job to set it up every single time the school wanted to use it. I couldn’t really lift anything, so I’d have to tell a custodian what to plug in, where to put things, when I was pretty little, I guess 8 or 9.

RA: I read that by the time you were in high school, you were putting in 12-14 hour days doing musicals, according to one of your teachers.

BB: [Laughs] Yeah, high school … it was kind of an amazing situation because when I arrived they had just renovated the high school and added a beautiful 700-seat theater, but nobody was in charge of it. So me and a bunch of friends started helping both the school and external people who were renting the space to put events on. They had a bunch of equipment which was installed wrong, basically, so my side hobby became fixing up the space [chuckles]. It was a lot of fun! There were like no adults involved, so it was sort of like Lord of the Flies or something!

RA: Referring to those years, you’ve said that “the amount of education that I missed out on is about 1/50th of the education I’ve gotten doing computer stuff.”  As a teacher, that presses a button for me in a good way. In New York State, there has been talk of remodeling our secondary school system to include paths for STEM (Science, Technology, Math, and Engineering) and other vocational choices rather than the straight liberal arts-focused academia. What is your take on that?

BB: That’s always been how I like to do things. I missed a lot of classes when I was in high school—I didn’t go to class very much because I was building things, fixing things, and what was so lucky for me was that my principal and my teachers, for the most part, understood that this was cool, and they let me do it. They let me break all the rules, basically, because they were supporting me. In a lot of places, that doesn’t happen. People get forced to do the usual things. It was nice for me, because I enjoyed helping people. A lot of times, putting on a production, people don’t really know, especially people that are renting a high school theater, they don’t really know the ins and outs of what’s going to feel good, what’s going to work well, the technology logistics, and so I just really enjoyed on that. When I got to college, as an undergrad, I travelled a whole lot. I did a thing called UROP at MIT which is an undergraduate research opportunity program and you can work in a research lab while you’re an undergrad, and you get paid for a campus job, and you actually get research experience as well.  My UROP was working for my current PhD advisor, Tod Machover. Back when I was an undergrad, I would mix all of his shows and then on tour with him. The Computer Science department hated it because I’d miss two weeks of school and come back two weeks before finals and have to get caught up and get through all that stuff, but again, I think wouldn’t trade it for anything, because you learn so much out on the road and, you know … I found myself—and this was at age 18 or 19—in charge of a union crew in France, and I didn’t speak French, and realizing the second day in that “stage left” and “stage right” are backwards! So, all these kinds of life lessons that you don’t get by just sitting in a classroom and doing your homework. I think that’s good, too, but I definitely gained a lot from sort of going out into the world and having some good adventures outside of the classroom.

RA: I learned something about you from someone I was speaking with at the Brooklyn show that you also sang at MIT. Checking your website, I see that you have years of musical experience ranging from classical and jazz piano to vocal jazz, along with guitar, bass, drums, alto and tenor sax. How old were you when you started playing piano?

BB: That was (in) first grade.

RA: From this musician’s point of view, your ability with sound is astounding. Again referring to the Brooklyn show, I noticed you stepping out from behind the board from time to time, and each time you returned it was to tweak the bass.
Working the board for the Jacob Collier Quartet
at The Roof at Output, Brooklyn, NY
September 1, 2017
image by Roy Abrams

BB: Every room has its strengths and its weaknesses. For me the goal is always tonal balance and a lot of times bass can be difficult because it’s either covering things up or it doesn’t feel big enough, and it’s hard to find the line where it fits just right. The other thing is, the bass that Jacob uses is not the best-sounding instrument [chuckles]… it’s one that fits in an overhead bin, so … [laughs] It’s a good one, but it’s always interesting on a big sound system to figure out how to get things to sit nicely.

RA: You’ve previously spoken about how important it is to control what the band hears. Absolutely! Why is it that some soundmen don’t seem to get that one?

BB: Well, I always feel that it’s important to experience it from both sides of the coin, basically. As a musician—again, granted nowhere near Jacob’s abilities—I‘ve been onstage and some of these guys haven’t. It’s just nice to kind of try and keep things in perspective and think, “What would I want if I were up there?” Having all these things going on … (a), you want to be able to know what’s going on but (b) and I think more importantly, you want to feel good. So a lot of mixing, for me, whether it’s in the studio or live, is just about finding something that feels good, that makes you feel good emotionally; good vibes. There are a lot of sound guys out there where, it’s a thing where it’s really easy to get kind of grumpy and jaded and forget why you’re doing it to begin with. I’m lucky, because I get to work with Jacob, and that’s never a problem, because it’s always unbelievably amazing working with him.
Good times working with Jacob Collier
image courtesy of Ben Bloomberg

RA: In your PBS interview, you were talking about how studio and stage production techniques have changed through the years and where you feel this might be heading. You talked about how both artists and fans love the live performance venue, given technological advances, there is something to be said for that multiple-theater concept of which you spoke.

BB: It’s really interesting. Everything’s getting so much smaller. It’s a funny thing about mixer design because you see all these new mixing desks coming out and they have fewer and fewer faders, and smaller and smaller and lighter and lighter. It’s great for saving shipping costs but I think that we’re actually losing quite a bit by not having the sort of physical controls. A lot of people say, “Oh, we replaced it all with touch screens,” but touch screens don’t allow you to have this muscle memory and that physical control that’s always in the same place; even if it’s a motorized fader that may do something different, so I always actually look for the consoles that have the most faders on them; the smallest package with the most faders, or you can add faders somehow. It’s interesting; we’re just trying to keep the costs down as much as we can. It’s unbelievable what $1,000 will do today for audio equipment and music equipment, we have basically a 40-channel console for not much more than $1,000. The challenge is always coming up with the ergonomics that allow you to—I always say that the feedback loop from your ear to your fingers is much faster than touch screen or anything you have to click on or use your mouse, so a lot of times you memorize where the faders are … you’re not looking at the desk when you’re mixing, you’re just sort of looking at the stage, you’re feeling the vibe, and you’re reacting without looking. I think the future of all of these devices … the best devices that technologies will sort of embrace that rather than throw away that style of interaction for something like a touch screen.

Explaining the finer points
image courtesy of Ben Bloomberg

RA: You’ve spoken a lot about the challenges and opportunities presented by working with Jacob. What were some of the challenges and opportunities presented by others with whom you’ve worked, such as Bjork and Imogen Heap?

BB: It’s always different. I know Imogen fairly well now. With Bjork, it’s mostly working with her team and it was sort of a consulting thing where they were asking me specifically about 360-dome kind of projection and surround sound technology. A lot of the challenges working with anybody is just getting on the same page and getting to the point where you trust each other about where the priorities are and what’s important. With Bjork, it was consulting for this Museum of Modern Art exhibit, and they ultimately ended up not having the funding to do what we wanted to do. I wrote all these briefs and all kinds of things, sort of trying to show that this is the way, the specific method of high-order ambisonics, would be a great way to do the exhibit, and they ended up not being able to do it, and … a lot of all these collaborations are just trust. For me, it always takes me a long time to get to know people, and then when I do know them, then we can say, “Okay, what are we really trying to do here? What’s really important?” Imogen, she uses a lot of technology—and actually it’s true of Jacob—everybody has sort of very grand dreams and the question is how to make people feel like we’re not neutering the entire idea but also achieve something that is realistically reliable and making a commitment that you can keep. There are a lot of tech people, especially in the live (arena), where somebody says, “I want this crazy thing!” and people say, oh yes, oh yes, they’ll do it, and they can’t do it or it doesn’t come through, so I think being able to communicate effectively what is possible and what’s important; those are always the challenges with everybody.

RA: There was only a 48-hour lead time before the first live show you did with Jacob?

Jacob Collier's "One-Man Show Creature"
image courtesy of Ben Bloomberg

BB: You mean in Montreux? Yeah! [Laughs] We had about 48 hours in Montreux. We had been working together previously; we did sort of a warm-up, late night thing at Ronnie Scott’s and actually before that, we rented out a space for four days in London, where we set the whole thing up. But the first iteration of the Harmoniser was also another 48-hour thing, and that was in Boston.

RA: Do you have any plans at some point to take these prototypes and make them publically available?

BB: I want to, but it’s a little bit of a challenge, because so many of these things are very highly tailored to Jacob, so I think the question is, which elements of it are important to get out there, and which elements are like, “Well, he usually plays “Close to You” after “Don’t You Worry” so we need this pitch shift to be 157 cents because that’s the difference between the last note of “Don’t You Worry” and the first note of “Close to You.” We’re also trying to push things so they’re continually sort of on the edge of stable, basically. [Laughs] We want to put something out there that people could use without getting frustrated. It wouldn’t be so bad to (offer) the essence of everything we’ve made. It’s just a matter of having the time to figure out exactly what that is and the best way to do it, but it is something to think about.

The "One-Man Live Show Creature"
image by Betsy Newman
RA: I see that you’ve been involved in many experimental projects. What have been some of your favorites?

BB: This robot opera that we did at MIT was an absolutely incredible project. It went on tour briefly; we did it as a live satellite broadcast that went to nine cities internationally as well as the stage production that was happening. That, to me, is the ultimate example of a performance—this was back in 2009, so it was really groundbreaking when we did it. It’s an example of a performance where the production infrastructure is completely interlinked; everything is connected to everything else, and everything can affect everything else. You might have a sensor that’s on the performer, and it’s affecting the robots that are driving around, and the lighting, and the sound, and the video, and the moving sets; everything, basically. That’s a really special one. I think that one will go down in history; that was a Pulitzer finalist. That was a really unique one in the history of our research group. I don’t know if we will do a bigger project than that! Other cool projects? We’ve done some stuff with stadium wireless communications. Imogen has these gloves and she gave a pair to Ariana Grande. They needed to figure out how to make these things work on a stadium tour where it was going to be 30,000 seats and we actually—it was me and a very close friend, Brian Mayton, worked with Shure to do some custom firmware, to basically turn this glove into a wireless microphone, and then that went out on tour for a whole year and a half. There have been a lot of interesting surround sound experiments; that’s another passion.

RA: I was looking at a video of the light show you were involved with at the CN Tower in Toronto—

BB: Yeah, that was another fun one! That was part of the Collaborative City Symphonies. This is another project with my advisor Tod Machover. He’ll work with an entire city—as many people as we could get involved, basically—to compose an entire symphony, and then it’s premiered in the city. For Toronto, what we did, we actually hooked the orchestra up to all the lighting on the CN Tower. You could stream the performance on your phone anywhere in the city and the CN Tower was lighting up in time to the music.

RA: That’s crazy—

BB: Yeah, that was one of those things where we were up all night the night before. There was a bug in the system that was running the tower lighting and they had never tried to do an animation of the magnitude we were trying to do on the tower before. We would load it in, and the whole thing would freeze. I actually had to take the whole lighting controller out of the tower and run in back to the hotel and we had to stay up all night trying to figure out a way to get the lighting system to behave with the amount of content that we had to put in there. We figured it out, and that was a really special one.

RA: One of the areas on your website discusses Multiplexed Performance. There was some fascinating material in there. I love the concept of using colored hats that the performers used to let the mixing engineers know what they wanted to hear. Did that idea come from you?

BB: Yeah.

RA: That’s great!

BB: That was for a project where we had a silent band; a band playing all silent instruments. We would basically have multiple sets of sounds coming out of these instruments so it could be an acoustic ensemble, it could be a lot of synthesized sounds, it could be something in the middle. The question was whether we could create multiple genres or how flexible you could be with these players playing the same physical thing but having it interpreted and mixed differently afterward. The way they would communicate what they wanted to hear was, we bought them a bunch of colored baseball hats … that was really cool. I’d like to try that again sometime; we didn’t really get to finish it. The final experiment was right during the Marathon bombing in Boston, so the whole thing was kind of cut short, but it was a really fun experiment.

RA: Death and the Powers was commissioned by Prince Albert of Monaco. How did that come about?

BB: That was the big robot opera, where everything was connected; it was a ten-year-long project, the Pulitzer finalist. This is what happens at the Media Lab, in our research group. We sort of attract the craziest people who have the biggest ideas, and so this one woman, she was very well-connected in the Monte Carlo opera, and she wanted to commission this present for the Prince, sort of as a birthday present, and so she asked around, and everybody said, “Go to Tod Machover,” who’s my advisor, and he’s the one that’s doing the craziest stuff out there. So she came to him; it was way before I was at MIT; it was probably about 2000, and the project’s premiere was in 2010, so I was lucky to come in. I started MIT in ’07, and I came in the last three years of the production on that project where I actually got to do it and I got to mix it, which was totally amazing.

RA: Let’s talk a bit about the venue versus “multiple-theater” concept. Do you see over time any kind of drop off in the actual face-to-face performance, or will it remain the current mix that we have today?

BB: It’s hard—I think that the makeup will slightly shift, but a lot of people that I work with now, in music, in theater, all of these different sorts of disciplines. When you design a live event, a big part of the creative process is, what makes this special because you’re here in the room right now with a certain group of people? Because people are thinking about that, it’s not going to be (that) these devices completely take over and we’re just going to sit at home in our VR headsets. I think there are still things that are special about real, live experiences, and we will continue to find them. It might be different, but I don’t see it going away.

RA: I found this statement from your website really interesting: “From a compositional perspective we know that pop music is relatively formulaic and many of the chords and progressions are following a trend of growing similarity. In fact this is happening to such a degree that very narrow technical differences (like a 7 BPM tempo shift in the case of EDM and trance) can define entire genres (each) with a separate fan-base and listenership.”  Is this really the case? I had no idea …

BB: Well, dance music is 128, and if it’s not 128—of course, there are exceptions—it’s very interesting to watch the trends in the Top 40. That was sort of the whole point of this multiplex project , was to see … these things are actually so close, can we make these subtle shifts to allow people to personalize. Maybe you write a piece of music that is more than something fixed; it can be molded or crafted a little bit by the person listening, depending on anything; it could be your mood, it could just be for fun. A lot of these things are growing in very clear trends and are similar in very certain ways and different in other ways.

RA: Do you have a favorite console?

BB: It really depends on the price bracket! [laughs] With a console, it can cost anywhere from $1,000 to $1,000,000! The system that we use right now is something that is found all over. Midas has this, and Behringer has this incredibly inexpensive (system). It’s called the X32 and for the money it’s unbeatable. As you start to go up in price, I’m a big fan of mixing desks which allow you to modify the actual underlying architecture of the mixer. A lot of mixers that you can buy have a fixed number of channels; you have 16 channels, and you get this many mix busses, and that’s that. But there are some really interesting mixers. Digico is one company, SSL is another company, even Roland has made mixers where you could say, well, I don’t need that many channels, but I need a whole lot of mix bussers, so let me trade some channels for some mix bussers, and so they have a set amount of processing power that you can decide what that power is used for. I tend to like those mixers because they allow me to better tailor the console for what’s it’s being used for.

RA: Any preferred microphones?

BB: It depends on the instrument and the specific person. I have a handful of (mics) that I have a good idea (of) how they sound, what their strengths are, and it really depends on what we’re doing. If you want something very bright, Mojave makes relatively inexpensive microphones, and they’re amazing. If you need some really smooth high end, you might be looking at a Neumann U87, if you’re looking for something warm and thick, something like a 47 might be better. There are crazy insanely expensive mics like the Sony C800G; it’s shiny pop high end is a classic. Sennheiser MKH800s are amazing for orchestral, incredibly detailed, incredibly low-noise but not necessarily as warm. The choice of preamp, too, makes a big difference, whether you’re doing something more Neve-like, which has transformers that behave a certain way, or something very transparent like a Grace or a Millennia-style preamp. These things have an effect; you can sort of use them like paintbrushes. On stage, a lot of what we do is try to connect feedback, it’s especially difficult when there’s a lot of looping going on. We usually use DPA 4099s on the piano, and those are great because they’re very natural and tonally balanced, but they have a very narrow pickup pattern. They’re really nice microphones (for) where you need a lot of gain where the instrument may be acoustic and may be quieter, but you want to be able to get it really loud and you want it to still feel natural.

RA: What advice would you have for students who are focusing on an audio engineering program? What would you advise them to really soak in and master?
Talking sound with Eric Gordon
at the Blue Note, NYC
June 20, 2017
image by Roy Abrams

BB: That’s a tough one. I think, for live sound, more than anything else, more than anything technical, it’s about your interactions with people onstage, and helping people feel comfortable and feel like they’re in an environment where the show can be the best it can be. A happy artist matters way more than any specific technical skill that you can have. You need to have skills to make people feel comfortable; you don’t want to seem like you don’t know what you’re doing, and therefore causing a lot of stress. For me it’s about finding common ground and feeling like we’re in it together and we’re going to treat this thing so we feel good about it and we feel good together. To me, that’s the most important thing. You can make most things sound good some way or another, and as long as everybody’s on the same page about expectations and these kinds of things, the tech stuff to me—I’m very excited by it and I love to play around with these things, but when you’re trying to make something musical and emotional, it’s more about choosing the vibe than it is about anything specific thing. A lot of people are afraid to break rules, especially in audio engineering school, they teach you all these rules: never do this; never do that. This results in some bad thing happening. I don’t think the rules are so hard and fast, especially in audio. It’s one thing if you’re a surgeon, in this world of sound, if somebody wants to try something, yeah—give it a shot! It’s all about experimentation. I never really learned anything formally with audio; it was just sort of trial and error. I think a lot of times, people get stuck in their ways, and they say, no, we’re only going to do it this one way, and this is definitely the best way … but no, try it! We do all kinds of really weird stuff sometimes [laughs] and some of it works and some of it doesn’t.

RA: So, you really approach everything that you do with the heart and mindset of a musician.

BB: Yeah, I would say so.
Ben Bloomberg
image courtesy of Ben Bloomberg

RA: I have previously spoken with Jacob about the stunning similarity in effect his music has upon me compared with the wonder of listening to early Beatles music when I was four … well, if I may be so bold, in your collaboration with Jacob, you bring a George Martin-like element to the mix.

BB: Oh, man. Yeah, actually I read Geoff Emerick’s book [the Beatles’ recording engineer]. I read his book and I guess I relate to a lot of the things they were doing. You know, back then when they started recording, you couldn’t put the mic closer than a foot to the kick drum. That just wasn’t done. The engineer couldn’t even touch the microphone! You had to make a diagram, and then they had guys in white lab coats that would come and put them in the right place. [laughs] So yeah, Geoff and George broke all these rules at Abbey Road, and I really respect that. And that’s one reason, on the album, we used this old Abbey Road term called “balance engineer” … we decided on that term rather than just mixing or something sort of more modern just as kind of an homage to them. We like their ideas and their philosophy.

© Roy Abrams 2017

Sunday, November 5, 2017

David Crosby: Happiness is a Warm Guitar

David Crosby and friend
image by Anna Webber

Well into his sixth decade as a recording and touring artist, David Crosby shows no signs of flagging; to the contrary, he has never been busier, and as he will tell you, he has never been happier. This August, the legendary singer-songwriter celebrated his 76th birthday. The two-time Rock and Roll Hall of Famer (as co-founder of both The Byrds and Crosby, Stills, and Nash) has just released his third solo album in four years, and is touring this fall in support of the new record. Fans and critics alike are marveling at the septuagenarian’s creative rebirth.

Sky Trails, released on September 29th, was produced by Crosby’s son, James Raymond, a fiercely talented songwriter and musician in his own right. The album is a jazz-inspired masterpiece, a stylistic departure from the shimmering, acoustic-based Lighthouse album of 2016, or its predecessor, the more electrified Croz from 2014. Musical guests adorn the album, from Michael McDonald and Jacob Collier to Becca Stevens and Michelle Willis. Early reviews have been laudatory, and the tour is off to a triumphant start, with both band and audience expressing unabashed glee resulting from an evening of shared sonic delight.

For those not deeply familiar with the wonderfully individualistic streak embedded in Crosby’s extraordinary body of work, consider these words from the Croz himself, spoken back in 1991 before unveiling a brand-new song to a live audience. “It’s another one of those ‘Crosby, what the hell is going on in my mind?!?’ songs.” As the audience breaks into laughter, he adds: “You gotta understand; if you have lived my life, you would have a lot of these songs!”

If you had lived my life,” indeed! From a logical standpoint, David Crosby should have departed for the spiritual realm a long, long time ago … but miracles can and do happen. Through a journey that spanned the soaring heights of groundbreaking musical innovation in the ‘60s and ‘70s to the blackest depths of addiction and despair in the ‘80s, from the long convalescence following a 1995 liver transplant to a warm, loving family life, Crosby has emerged fully intact, fully present; fully aware of and in charge of his creative faculties to an extent perhaps previously imagined, but never before achieved until the past few years. While he credits his many newfound collaborators with raising the bar and inspiring him to reach higher, at the end of the day it is Crosby, the golden-voiced balladeer, the patriotic town crier, the ever-questing mind and soul of the man himself responsible for a late-stage creative renaissance unparalleled in recent times.

image by Anna Webber

Having maintained a professional dialogue for more than 25 years, the chance to spend some time with a lifelong musical inspiration is always a special event. In late September, I had the opportunity to once again speak with David. Once again, there was so much to discuss: a brand-new album and pending tour, new musical collaborators, an ongoing track record of discovering and promoting new musical talent, the state of the music business and the extent to which the streaming services have impacted the lives of artists, the state of our country, the future of our world, and yes … CSNY.

As always, I am deeply indebted to David Crosby for his time spent speaking with me, and for a lifetime of musical and philosophical inspiration.

Roy & Yvonne Abrams with David Crosby
May 18, 2017, The Space at Westbury
image courtesy of Roy Abrams

Roy Abrams: So, here we are, speaking for the third time in less than a year! This is amazing, sir!

David Crosby: [Laughs] I thought I recognized the name!

RA: I read on Facebook that Becca (Stevens) was coming over today to write?

DC: Yeah! She’s here right now.

RA: You have described the past few years as like jumping off a cliff, then growing wings while you were halfway down. On the basis of what’s been created in that time, I daresay you’re flying higher than ever before, musically speaking. How’s the view from that altitude?

DC: You know, I feel wonderful. I think I’m doing the right thing, and I’m having a blast doing it.

RA: It sounds it! Sky Trails, to me, exudes vitality, innovation, intelligence, the degree of loving care with which the album was recorded and executed, and most importantly, the insane amount of fun that was had by you and everybody else (on the record).

DC: You could tell, huh? [Chuckles]

RA: Can we talk about the time frame of the writing and recording sessions of the new album, relative to Lighthouse?

DC: As we finished the Lighthouse record, I just stayed in the studio and started the Sky Trails record. I had the songs, we were already writing the songs; we already had songs to cut; we just started right and in started working. I’m just lucky. I feel really lucky.

RA: Audiences first got to hear some of these new tracks performed live earlier this year. Were the same personnel on the spring/summer tour also featured on the album? (The touring band—then and now—is comprised of James Raymond, keyboards/vocals; Michelle Willis, keyboards/vocals; Mai Agan, bass; Jeff Pevar, guitar/vocals; and Steve DiStanislao, drums/vocals.)

DC: Yeah. There are other people on the record that are not in the touring band. Greg Leisz played steel (guitar) all over the record; he’s a wonderful player. Steve Tavaglione played horn all over the record; he’s not on the road with us. Everybody else is pretty much there.

RA: I know that Michael McDonald co-wrote “Before Tomorrow Falls on Love”, you co-wrote the title track with Becca Stevens, and reading the liner notes from the 2017 Tour Limited Edition CD I purchased at the gig back in May, I see that Mai Agan also wrote with you. What did she contribute?

DC: That song, “Here It’s Almost Sunset” … I had that set of words and she said, “Oh, please, I really like that set of words. Let me take a shot at it.” And she wrote the music. That’s our first song together. I guarantee we’re going to write some more!

RA: What you’re doing with Becca is also off the charts—between “By the Light of Common Day” from Lighthouse and “Sky Trails,”—evidences an umbilical collaborative relationship. Are you planning on doing an entire record with her at some point?

DC: I’m going to do another record with that band, the Lighthouse Band, with Becca, Michelle (Willis), myself, and Michael League. We’re going to do another record with the four of us. What I did was … I was so thrilled with that record that I asked them to do another record with me, and this time (to) not have it be a David Crosby record with them on it but a “four of us” record with all four of us writing and singing.

RA: I hear our mutual friend Jacob Collier singing on the opening track, “She’s Got to Be Somewhere.” How did you meet Jacob?

DC: (Through) Snarky Puppy, the same way that I met Becca and Michelle.

RA: I’ve seen him five times within the past twelve months and spoke with him back in January.

DC: Isn’t he just beyond-belief good?

RA: He’s an enormous fan of yours.

DC: So much talent. He’s probably the most talented kid I’ve run into. He’s just unbelievably good.

David in the studio with Jacob Collier

RA: I’m thinking about his harmonic sensibilities, yours, and then James (Raymond)’s …. If you were to assign those harmonic sensibilities a weight, with that opening song, you could probably tip the earth a bit on its axis.

DC: [Hearty laugh] Ah, thank you, man. I loved it! I want very badly to write with Jacob. We’ve been trying to get together in the same place at the same time. We think that we could write together as well.

RA: Manna from heaven … which is, actually, how your longtime fans are viewing what’s happened with your creative output during the past few years. By your own admission, in decades past, you had said that you only wrote three or four songs a year, and there was a time when the muse wasn’t visiting … but now, apparently, it’s with you all the time.

DC:  Yeah! I’ll tell you what happened, man. I kind of had a head of steam built up from being in Crosby, Stills, and Nash and it being not good. It certainly wasn’t a place I could bring a song to and hope to get it on a record. We just didn’t like each other and we were sort of down to, you know, “turn-on-the-smoke-machine-and-play-your-hits” kind of level. So I think this burst of stuff was just wanting to happen. I think a big part of it is these people that I’m writing with; I think I’ve been very, very lucky with that.

RA: About the physical recording of Sky Trails, I know that James was involved with that; was that done using analog, digital or hybrid technology?

DC: Hybrid. We were using digital—I forget if we were using Logic or ProTools—but there are stages where we do some trick stuff with tape as well.

RA: Your love of jazz is more in full flower on the new record than probably at any point in the past, although you’ve always spoken about it, specifically regarding the work of John Coltrane and Miles Davis. You’ve also noted the influence of McCoy Tyner on your chording and voicing sensibilities on the guitar. What is more personally alluring to you, jazz’s improvisational nature or its complexity?

DC: Both. Yeah, I wouldn’t try to separate one from the other. The improvisational nature inspires me; I’m not good enough to improvise very much except vocally, a little, but the improvisational and the complexity both appeal to me greatly.

RA: In Dave Zimmer’s book, you described the acquisition of alternate guitar tunings as “like having a rocket ship in my pocket.”

DC: Ah!

RA: Does playing in standard tuning seem mundane or limiting in comparison?

DC: Well, no, because I get weird in standard tuning, too! [Extended laughing]

RA: Point taken!

DC: [Still laughing] I can’t help it!

image by Anna Webber

RA: Moving back to the album, you had released “Capitol” almost as soon as it was finished, months before the record had an actual release date. To my ears, I don’t think a more incisive indictment of our country’s current political dysfunction exists. It’s very much in keeping with your prior acknowledgement of the “town crier” element of the singer-songwriter-troubadour. I was reminded of the 2006 CSNY tour, and how you guys became the collective voice of outrage over the political cesspool of those times. I also know that you recently spoke about the urge to resurrect that four-piece as a voice for today’s protest movement. First, I was blown away by that because of how busy you already are in moving forward with all things new, but also because you’re headlining a show at Carnegie Hall in January, billed as “an evening of protest music, with special guests,” Might this be an opportunity for some kind of event like that to occur?

DC: No. It’ll be good; there’ll be some recognizable music and I think it’s going to be a very fascinating thing. But no, I think that if CSNY gets together, it’ll be because Neil (Young) wants to do it. He’s the deciding factor, always has been. If he decides he wants to do it then God bless him, we will do it!

RA:  Your followers on Twitter know that you are an outspoken, outraged critic of the streaming services, and how the practice has essentially killed record sales for both established artists and those just starting out. On one of those threads, someone suggested adding a virtual Tip Jar to the services so listeners can contribute.

DC: I think that anything that would help us is a great idea, because as it stands now, man, I made these three records out of the grocery money, and the help of a friend. A close friend of mine bought me a month of studio time that I couldn’t afford. Why couldn’t I afford it? Because they’re stealing my music and not paying me for it. That’s how this winds up. Young people just don’t stand a chance. It’s incredibly difficult, because there’s no payoff. They take the music and they sell it, and they make billions of dollars, and they don’t pay us; it’s that simple.

RA: Are there any thoughts circulating in the industry, or among your musician friends, on how artists—or the public—can effect that kind of change to revamp the system?

DC: There’s many people trying to come up with an answer to it, man. Some of them are trying some way to encrypt or watermark a digital file so that it can’t be copied; I think that’s not gonna work, because there’s always some guy in Russia someplace figuring out a way to find their way in. I think—I don’t know—maybe some kind of new technology. Just because I don’t have an answer how to fix it doesn’t mean that it’s okay what they’re doing. What they’re doing is theft.

RA: I could not possibly agree more. What’s the percentage for artists? Point-zero-zero-zero-zero-zero-zero-zero ad infinitum? That’s criminal! The last time we spoke, you talked about how live performances have become a necessary means of survival.

DC: Live performance is the only way we make any money. At all.

RA: I know how much you have always loved performing and connecting with your fans. I’m wondering if your feelings toward the streaming services that make this kind of frequent touring a necessity ever impact how you feel about the touring schedule?

DC: No, the touring schedule is just tough. It’s always been tough. For me, it’s particularly hard, because I’m not a kid any more. I’m an old guy and I don’t have the kind of stamina I used to have. It’s very hard on me. But I love singing, I love singing, I really do. And when I do it, I feel overjoyed. I think it couldn’t be a better thing for me.  The other 21 hours a day are very rough.  We don’t get more than three or four hours of sleep in a row; we never get home cooking, we’re always eating in bad restaurants, bad food … the road beats the crap out of you, man. It’s hard. It’s not an easy thing at all, but it’s the only way I can make a living.

RA: You’ve always been so encouraging toward other musicians. What’s been blowing my mind as of late is your willingness to listen to aspiring artists online and offer them your feedback. I don’t know of any other artist on your level who would do such a thing. What motivates you to be so generous with your time?

DC: Well, they’re at the stage that I remember very, very well … like driving 200 miles to go play to another 35 people, making just enough money to put gas in the rented van and maybe buy one meal. It’s insanely difficult for young people now. So, yeah, I think it’s a righteous thing to try and help them get attention and try to help them get known, if they’re talented enough. I do look for really talented people. I mean, I discovered Joni Mitchell and Jackson Browne, so I’m not batting too badly.

RA: And it almost feels like you’re reading from my notes! [Laughs] That was my next point. You’ve always shown this sheer joy at making those introductions. As you said, Joni and Jackson, and you continued with Michael Hedges—and I will be eternally grateful to you for that introduction.

DC: A great cat, man. Shit, was he good!

RA: Most recently, it continues with Becca and Michelle. You know, I can’t get over the simpatico between you and Becca especially. In a similar vein in which you, Stephen, and Graham locked voices in the past, you’re locking muses with Becca, and the results are mind-blowing!

DC: We do write well together. She’s here today, and she’s gonna be here for the next couple of days, we’re trying to start on the next song, because we love writing together.

RA: As far as James is concerned, I know that you guys have written together for years. Love the CPR material! What were the co-writes with him on Sky Trails?

DC: James wrote the first song by himself, James and I wrote “Home Free” together. Michael McDonald and I wrote “Before Tomorrow Falls on Love” together, James and I wrote “Capitol,” “Sell Me a Diamond” and “Curved Air” together. I wrote “Somebody Home” by myself. And there’s the Joni Mitchell one (“Amelia”).

RA: What made you choose that one of hers in particular?

DC: Man, I’ve always loved that song! It’s a brilliant song. It’s a daunting prospect, trying to sing a song that Joni’s already sung, but I just couldn’t resist it because the song is so good.

RA: Another artist I want to ask you about is Kenny White. He opened for Stephen Stills and Judy Collins back in August—

DC: —Isn’t he good??

RA: Let me tell you—I don’t think anybody else in that room had ever heard of him. The man got a standing ovation at the end of his set. So, after the concert, I did some research at home, and there you are, singing harmony with him on “A Road Less Traveled.” What or who was your introduction to him?

DC: He is very close friends with a neighbor of mine, whom I am very, very tight friends with; his name is Dan Gerber. Dan turned me on him and once I heard him … I love him. He’s a wonderful songwriter, a wonderful musician. He’s a really great cat.

image by Anna Webber

RA: I’m sure everyone and their grandparents have been asking you your thoughts on the current political environment. Where do you see this going? Do you see us collectively waking up?

DC: I don’t know, man. It’s pretty tough—a pretty tough situation that we could wind up with this asshole getting elected in the first place. Isn’t it terrible that we could be so asleep that the Russians could get away with what they got away with? That our system is so broken that our Congress does nothing but fight like babies in a schoolyard? The ways to fix it don’t look even possible. You’d have to publicly finance elections so that the corporations couldn’t buy the elections and thereby own the Congress, which is where the situation is right now. And of course, you’d never get that through Congress!

RA: As a teacher of high school students, I see so many of them taking the time to independently research, and when they’re done researching, they research some more …

DC: They’re grown up being able to. They’ve grown up with Google.

RA: And by doing the research, they’re also able to make very well-educated decisions. That actually gives me a lot of hope for the future—

DC: —If they become active and they vote!

RA: Absolutely!           

DC: A whole lot of people didn’t vote in this last election. If they had, we wouldn’t have this asshole running the country.

RA: So, David Crosby and Friends will be coming to the Concert Hall at the NY Society for Ethical Culture in New York City on November 25th. How extensive is your touring schedule this time around?

DC: About a month and a half, starting right at the end of October.

RA: I still listen to Lighthouse every day, and now Sky Trails joins it in constant replay. I have two wonderful new musicians who you’ve introduced me to, Becca and Michelle. My playlist is full of material that is directly related or attributable to you. Thank you so much.

DC: Thank you, man.

image by Anna Webber

© Roy Abrams 2017